Test Optional Isn't What You Think It Is
When test optional policies exploded across American colleges during the pandemic, a lot of families breathed a collective sigh of relief. No more Saturday mornings at a testing center. No more prep courses. No more agonizing over whether a 1280 would hurt more than it would help. And for some students, that relief was entirely warranted. But for many others — particularly high-achieving students applying to selective schools — test optional has become one of the most misunderstood and potentially costly policies in the modern college process. After nearly three decades inside high-performing schools and now working one-on-one with families navigating this landscape, I want to set the record straight. Test optional does not mean tests do not matter. It means you have a choice about whether to submit them. And that choice has real strategic consequences that most families are not thinking about carefully enough. What Test Optional Actually Means When a college declares itself test optio...